After last episode’s breakneck action, we are treated to this astounding character episode. After stating that last week’s episode was one of the best the series had done, we get this episode that is easily as good, and is without a doubt one of the best episodes this series has done. If last week’s episode should be enough to finally get Battlestar their much deserved visual effects and directing Emmy awards, this episode should be easily enough to get the show a writing Emmy. Of course, those are assumptions based on the Academy actually being filled with people who know what in the world quality television really is. So, in other words, highly unlikely. As even Ron Moore admits in his podcast, this episode is about as dark as the show can get. I agree. Not only is it dark, it’s an episode of television that I simply haven’t seen before. This is characters living every shade of gray, lost in a haze of ambiguity and disillusionment. There aren’t heroes and bad guys to this story. This is the characters of the show in a state of apathy and confusion, seeking vengeance wherever they can get it. The opening of the episode is such a starkly dark open you know you’re in for one heck of an episode. By this point, I’m convinced that the Sci-Fi Channel is 100% behind this show. Any network that wasn’t completely committed to a show wouldn’t produce and put an episode like this on the air. This is brave television. This is brilliant television. This is what the medium should be used for.
It’s extremely clear (to me, anyway) just how versed in history the writers of this show are. Or more to the point, how versed they are in the history of warfare. There are many allusions to post WWII (and numerous other conflicts) fallout, with hugely difficult questions raised. And they have the bravery to not really answer the questions, choosing instead to show both sides of the problem, and admitting that neither side of the argument is a clear cut moral high ground. The final solution, if you want to call it that, is a smart choice. When Roslin and Adama confront Zarek about his tactics, clearly assuming themselves to be in the right, he comes back at them with a great many insightful points. Raising the notion that public trials for stuff like this will become a baseless witch-hunt, more so than his appointed squad of justice, Adama and Roslin are faced with the fact that he’s right about that. I mean, if you look at the history of war crime trials, you realize that things become so buried in revenge and blind remorse that it’s likely more just and better for society as a whole to have a small set of people take care of it all discreetly. This episode is filled with intense character development, to an almost pathological intensity. Aaron Douglas beautifully portrays a Chief Tyrol who has completely lost his bearings, who can’t figure out what he’s supposed to be doing. What’s the right call? He has no idea, and he knows it. Tigh’s point of view is even more stark – coming from the angle that if his wife had to face justice, why should anyone else be shown compassion. Ellen’s final fate is something that was shrouded in questionable action, and in retrospect is much more interesting after watching an episode like this. Then there’s the cast, who bring this story to another level. Aaron Douglas is yet again a major standout talent on the show. Michael Hogan brings out the truly raw side of Tigh. Katee Sackhoff keeps Starbuck spinning out of control, a talent which she has in spades. Richard Hatch makes a very challenging situation for his character of Tom Zarek work – he is completely convincing as a character who is doing very harsh things, almost intolerable, for the right reasons. Plenty of the other cast members do fantastic jobs as well.
This episode is intelligent TV of the highest order. It deserves and Emmy. It deserves another Peabody. It deserves higher ratings. The Sci-Fi Channel has the best show on TV, and they are stopping at nothing to keep it that way. They are not pulling any punches, and are giving the writers and producers of the show something that is so completely rare on TV – a nearly free reign to present challenging storylines, full of unanswerable questions and questionable action. This episode is not easy to watch – which is in no way a criticism. There are so few examples of episodes like this in the history of television. Epsiodes like Buffy’s “The Body” (which is quite different from this episode, but is another example of an unflinchingly dark story told without sugarcoating or apology). This just leaves me with mentioning the small introductory bits of Baltar’s new storyline, on the basestar. We are only teased with that storyline, and what’s there is good. There’s much more of that storyline to come, and much of it already sounds promising. We’ll be seeing far more detail of the until-now elusive basestar interiors in episodes to come, and I look forward to what the writing/design teams have come up with. So, to sum up, I consider this one of the strongest episodes of any show in recent years, right on the heels of last week’s phenomenal episode. Stunning stuff, guys. Keep up the fantastic work.